Many industrial owners, such as clay mines or brickworks, face a dilemma: is it worth replacing an old transformer, especially if it’s still functioning? At first glance, it may seem like maintaining a working, albeit outdated device, is a cost-saving move. Nothing could be further from the truth. Using an old transformer not only leads to massive energy losses and higher operational costs but also poses a serious safety risk to the facility and its workers.

The Risk of Disasters: What Could Happen?

Transformers produced in the 1960s, although solid for their time, are not designed to meet modern requirements and safety standards. Overheating, which results from their lower efficiency, can lead to serious failures, such as fires. Additionally, aging insulation and internal components of transformers are more prone to cracking and mechanical damage.

Fires in transformers are a real threat, which can result not only in infrastructure damage but, more importantly, in endangering the lives of workers.

An Example of the Energy Efficiency of Replacing Old Transformers for Mines and the Brickmaking Industry

Imagine a clay mine using a 150 kVA transformer from the 1960s with an efficiency of around 94%. A modern transformer compliant with DOE 2016 standards offers an efficiency of 98.83%.

A seemingly small 4.83% difference in efficiency translates into annual savings of about 10,000 kWh, which results in approximately 1500 USD in reduced energy expenses annually. Over several years, these figures grow, while the risk of sudden failures decreases.

The costs associated with the failure of an old transformer can be enormous. In the case of a sudden breakdown, the production plant may come to a standstill, generating additional losses.

In clay mines or brickworks, where operational continuity is crucial, a transformer failure can mean losses of hundreds of thousands of USD.

Freepik

Transformer failures can cause losses of hundreds of thousands of USD, and more importantly, they pose a threat to the health and even the lives of those working nearby.

Old transformers often operate at low loads, which leads to greater energy losses. Modern devices are designed with variable demand in mind, making them much more efficient, even at lower loads. Moreover, modern technologies are better equipped to handle harmonic disturbances, which can cause additional losses in older devices.

Old transformers, especially those from the 1960s, do not meet modern safety and energy efficiency standards. Over time, their internal components, such as insulation, wear out, increasing the risk of short circuits, fires, or even explosions. Such failures can not only cause production downtime but also pose a real threat to the health and lives of workers.

For instance, older transformers have higher core losses (no-load losses) and load losses (winding losses). Older technologies were less energy efficient, meaning such devices operate at much lower efficiency compared to their modern counterparts.

What’s more, the costs of repairing or replacing damaged equipment in an emergency are much higher than planned, preventive replacement with a modern unit.

Why Replace a Transformer Before It Fails?

Energy savings: Modern transformers are more efficient, which means lower energy bills.

Minimized risk of failure: Older devices are more prone to unpredictable failures that can lead to costly downtimes.

Safety: Modern transformers comply with strict safety standards, reducing the risk of accidents in the facility.

Compliance with new standards: New units meet energy efficiency requirements, which can also help reduce CO2 emissions.

Savings and Return on Investment

Let’s return once again to calculations based on real quantitative data affecting overall quality. Let's recall the example:

An old 150 kVA transformer operating at 94% efficiency consumes much more energy than a modern model with 98.83% efficiency. With continuous operation throughout the year (8760 hours), the 4.83% efficiency difference translates into annual savings of 10,000 kWh, which equates to about 6,000 PLN annually (1500 USD).

A Tier 2 compliant transformer can reduce energy losses by up to 50% compared to older models from the 1950s or 60s. No-load losses, which occur when the transformer is connected to the grid, can be significantly reduced, positively impacting the energy balance of the entire facility.

The cost of replacing an old transformer may seem high – estimated at around 20,000 USD

– but considering energy savings, the investment pays off in 6-8 years.

Moreover, modern transformers require less maintenance, further reducing operating costs.

Freepik

Climate Change and Regulations

An equally important aspect is the environmental impact. The IPCC emphasizes that modernizing energy infrastructure, including replacing old transformers, is a key step in reducing CO2 emissions and achieving sustainable development goals.

Old transformers that do not meet Ecodesign Tier 2 standards are responsible for significant energy losses. Introducing new units can reduce emissions and improve the resilience of the grid to climate changes.

Technological Advances and Energy Savings

If you are considering replacing an old transformer, our offer could be the key to solving many of your facility's energy problems. Maybe your 1960s transformer is working fine, but ask yourself:

Is it working efficiently enough?

Imagine a scenario where your transformer not only stops being a problem but becomes a key element of savings. With new technologies, you can reduce energy costs by thousands of PLN annually, avoiding failures and costly downtimes.

Our team of experts will not only help you select a transformer optimally suited to the needs of your mine or production plant but will also conduct a cost-benefit analysis so that you can clearly see how quickly the investment will start paying off.

It’s time to take advantage of the opportunity!

How to Prepare for Transformer Replacement?

A transformer, like an old tree in the forest of energy systems, can serve faithfully for decades. But like any hero, the time comes when it needs retirement, and you must arrange for a new successor.

Replacing a transformer is not just a technical issue; it’s an opportunity to optimize costs, reduce energy losses, and prepare for the future. Here are some essential steps to help you go through this process like a pro:

Understand the age and condition of the current transformer: An older transformer, especially one from the 1960s, can generate huge energy losses. Replacement is not just modernization but an investment in lower bills and greater efficiency.

Research energy loss regulations: New EU regulations impose strict standards on energy losses – your new transformer should meet Ecodesign Tier 2 standards. Choose wisely, as the difference in performance between older and newer models is enormous.

Check space availability: Modern transformers are often larger than their older counterparts. Ensure you have enough space in your transformer station before placing an order.

Prepare a return on investment analysis: Modern transformers not only save energy but also money. It’s worth preparing an ROI analysis to convince management to decide on modernization.

Plan ahead: Transformer availability can be challenging, and producing new models takes time. Plan the replacement well in advance to avoid energy supply interruptions.

Freepik

Eco2 Series by Energeks

Transformer technology has changed dramatically, and modern solutions, such as MarkoEco2 and TeoEco2 from Energeks, offer real energy and financial savings.

MarkoEco2, an oil transformer, combines reliability with high energy efficiency. It offers power up to 4550 kVA and is ideal for heavy industry and large facilities. With its hermetic design and modern protection systems, it guarantees longevity and minimizes losses.

TeoEco2, a resin transformer, eliminates the need for oil, reducing the risk of fire. With high power and corrosion resistance, it is perfect for critical infrastructure and renewable installations.

By choosing our transformer tailored to your business needs, you gain reliability, safety, and compliance with Ecodesign Tier 2 requirements, which translates into long-term savings as energy prices rise.

Whether you have an old machine from the past that is slowly generating more losses than profits, or you are just considering optimizing your energy infrastructure – Energeks is your partner on the path to a better, more efficient future.

Contact us, and you will see that replacing a transformer is not just a decision about new equipment but about real savings and reliability for years to come!

Sources:

NY Engineers

Wilson Power Solutions

Consulting - Specifying Engineer